Pizza Star

Reviews

• Lindsey P.

  star star star star star 21 July 2026

  Pizza star is Hands The best pizza places in the area, I have been eating there pizza since  I was a little child, either pipeing hot or cold in the fridge there pizza is to die for. everyone says "slices" is the best pizza around, but I beg to differ. Pizza star is reasonably priced and the staff is sweet and understanding. slices is over expensive. if you're looking for a quick bite or just have a meal with friends or family this is the place to go

• Marysa N.

  star star star star star 20 July 2026

  We stopped at this restaurant after an exhausting hike at Overlook Mountain. The downtowns areas of Woodstock and Saugerties were both quite packed so we stopped in at Pizza Star, which was easy to find with plenty of parking.
  
  Inside, the restaurant is very clean and modern. The menu was displayed on an electronic display, and there was lots of seating.
  
  We ordered garlic knots, a pizza and some drinks. The food came out quickly (much appreciated when you have kids who are hungry), and was surprisingly good.  Everything was tasty and it hit the spot after a long hike out of town - plus, the prices are all very reasonable.
  
  The bathrooms were also very clean.
  
  Great place with great service. The employees were helpful and friendly.  Will definitely go back if we are in the area. The kids got some desserts from the cooler when we were done with lunch.

• Joni V.

  star star star star star 18 July 2026

  I lived in Saugerties as a kid, and moved away in 1992. Back then Pizza Star was between Jamesway and Grand Union, and was the best pizza I've ever had. It is still the bar that I measure other pizzas to.
  Fast forward 26 years, and we took a vacation back to visit family. I had raved about Pizza Star to my husband, and he was dubious of my claims that it is THE BEST PIZZA EVER, thinking my judgement was clouded by time.
  Let me tell you: HE WAS WRONG!!!
  I was so worried that it had changed, but that went out the window- new location, same pizza! The best crust, the best seasoning in the sauce, and the best fold. We live in Arizona, and I don't think we can (HONESTLY!!!) get any pizza in our state that tastes so good- and at such an amazing price!!! Damn I wish Pizza Star could be cloned!!!

• Larry D.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 11 July 2026

  I don't have a problem with the pizza, and that's all the food I've ever gotten from there, so that's all I can comment on. But the attitudes on the guys working there are horrible.I just left there. For the last time.

• Jeff W.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 8 July 2026

  I have eaten here on 4 diffetent occasions; each experience worse than the last. Unfortunately it is open later than most places so i gave them 4 different chances, the pizza sucks the dishes suck and the sandwhichs suck service was not any better and the attitudes are even worse. Try Fredericos in the shopping center next door or slices on Main st.Their food was so bad I had to break my cardinal rule and eat McDonald's because it was the only other place open, anyone who knows me knows mcdonalds is no no for me so that tells you how bad it was